How Much Does ButcherBox Cost? Loving My High Quality Meat

by Josh | Last Updated:  August 28, 2020
Eat.Lift.Sleep. is owned and operated by EatLiftSleep.com. Eat.Lift.Sleep. is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Eat.Lift.Sleep. also participates in affiliate programs with Avantlink, Impact, Clickbank, CJ, ShareASale, and other sites. Eat.Lift.Sleep. is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies.

When I was looking at how to get high quality grass fed meats to my home I was hard pressed to find any good deals from the farmers markets. Instead I chose to look into ButcherBox and almost 3 years later I am still receiving a box monthly with the best beef, pork, and chicken.

How much does ButcherBox cost? The standard box from ButcherBox comes in at $129 but there is options for each month or every other month. You can increase your costs and actually receive double the meat in each box, the cost doesn’t change based on your meat preference choice though.

I would say that it is a very good cost when you look at the overall ability to get quality raised animal meat and not the candy fed crap that exists today overall in the world.

When I started the ketogenic diet there was a promise to myself to work on purchasing better quality foods for myself and my family.

What I found out is that the farmers markets near me frequently were hit or miss with any specific meat cuts I was interested in and that unless I was very early many times they would be sold out by the time I could get there.

Is Butcher Box Worth the Price?

Then I found ButcherBox and their team of small farmers. My friend had recently ordered the Butcher Box with a mix of all 3 meats: beef, chicken and pork. He raved on and on about the pork sausage and the bacon he had received. I decided at that point that I would give them a try.

ButcherBox has been amazing for my family and I to have quality meats delivered monthly for nearly no cost difference but a much larger quality difference from the store.

Josh

The first box arrived and I fell in love as I got all the meat from tasty sources. I have ordered continuously now for almost a year and have received more choice meats than anyone could ever hope for.

It included quality beef from steak tips to NY Strip and more, chicken thighs and breasts that are amazingly tasty. The pork sausage my wife and I could eat forever, I now add 2 pounds to my box each month.

As to cost, with the time savings to find grass fed high quality meats I save an infinite amount on not shopping around and I get some of the most tasty meat I’ve eaten and I will say it is more than worth the price!!!

How Does ButcherBox Work?

ButcherBox features exclusively 100% Grass Fed/Grass Finished Beef, Organic Chicken & Heritage Breed Pork. If you haven’t had heritage pork before you will fall in love with the taste and texture. I don’t ever eat any other pork if I can help it!

I would suggest going with the mixed box as your first shipment and then possibly migrate to the custom for a more specific selection to receive.


There’s no way to substitute for standards. That’s why we pay special attention to every step of the process. From food to bedding, our animals are cared for. We make sure to accommodate their natural tendencies – cattle like to roam, hogs like to move dirt with their snouts, and chickens like to peck.

After all, quality is influenced by how the animal lived: Was it healthy and content? Was it ever given antibiotics or hormones? Was it humanely raised on a farm with sustainable practices?
These are the questions we ask, and you should too.

Butcher Box On Sourcing Their Meats

Mixed Box (Beef, Chicken And Pork)

Includes 8 1/2 to 11 lbs of meats from a mix of different cuts and animals. This is the default and most common ordered box from ButcherBox and will work for almost anyone looking to get started.

I have been on this one a majority of my time while on the service. I like the variety and ability to look and find matching recipes to compliment the meats.

Beef And Chicken

This is situated towards the people who aren’t interested in pork products, this could be the box for you if you enjoy Crossfit and workouts and are looking for lean cuts of meat. I would recommend starting here if that’s your flow and then moving to custom later to align your box to your exact needs.

Beef And Pork

These are definitely the more fatty cuts of meat and not aimed at those looking to skimp on their fat intake. I would love to order this box but my wife is a chicken fan so we stuck to custom or mixed boxes 99% of the time we have ordered.

All Beef

This is the Carnivores dream box, especially since most stick to a predominantly beef meal plan. This is the one Shawn Baker more than likely orders. I like more variety to my dishes and the ability to try different meats on different days will keep me away from choosing this option.

Custom Box

This one is where it is at, you have to pay extra for the choice and selection but each box is to your liking in every way. This is definitely the box for those who are picky in their choice of cuts and options as to type of meats or to fit a macro nutrient ratio. Definitely worth it if you want to drill down and get specific steaks, chicken, or pork selections.

How Does ButcherBox Ship? Every Month Or Every Other Month

ButcherBox has a lot of options but they dial down them to the two simple options listed below which are 24-48 servings each month or every other month.

Once A Month (24 or 48 Servings)

This is a personal preference and the more you eat in the more you should evaluate based on family size whether you need 24 or 48 servings within a month of time. We stick to the 24 servings per month as we eat around 3oz per serving so we stretch this a little further.

If you are a large family you would want to definitely look into the 48 servings to allow you the ability to feed a 3-4 person family better for the month. You may still need to supplement with a little more from the grocery here or there depending on your meat consumption.

Every Other Month (24 or 48 Servings)

This is similar to above but they only ship to you every other month. This means you get either 24 or 48 servings sent to you bi-monthly so this is a more long term planning of meals and knowing that you will need to supplement on occasion or eat out.

How Long Can ButcherBox Stay Outside?

Each box is carefully package with dry ice and an insulated box to ensure the temperature doesn’t fail while delivered and waiting for you outside. It is expected that you would bring in the box sooner than about 6 hours, after this time frame you may start to have questions on the meat.

Should you be wondering on the viability of your delivery you will want to check it immediately yo ensure that the temperature is below 40°F as measured with a food thermometer.

Monthly Specials

The ButcherBox monthly specials have ranged from Turkeys available for arrival prior to Thanksgiving to an amazing 6lbs of Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon. ButcherBox always provides unique and tasty monthly specials onto their boxes available for a small additional cost. Our turkey this last thanksgiving was from them and was probably the best tasting turkey I have had in ages.

Where Does ButcherBox Meat Come From?

ButcherBox supports smaller farmers and processors which means that you aren’t getting big-agra meats but more carefully tended animals.

ButcherBox strives for excellence in every area, and that includes working with the best possible meat processing facilities. We work with companies and farmers that are dedicated to doing the right thing – never cutting corners, and always looking for ways to improve.

Every facility operates based on the principles set out by Dr Temple Grandin, and is equipped with the latest technology. They are inspected and approved by the USDA or a comparable agency, and there is someone on site at all times to ensure our products surpass safety standards.

ButcherBox On Processing Facilities

ButcherBox Guarantees

ButcherBox does offer guarantees on your orders and that they will make it to you safe to consume without worry. They also guarantee the sources and quality in their meats that are shipped out.

Beef

They guarantee ButcherBox beef is 100% grass-fed and finished. They let cattle free range on grassy pastures throughout their life. They are provided access to shelter only when weather or other impact requires it. Being grass fed means they are full of key nutrients like Omega 3 Fatty Acids, vitamins and minerals.

Chicken

Our free range organic chickens spend their lives roosting in barns and exploring outside. Along with thoughtful enhancements such as hay bales and places to climb (chickens love to jump up to high places!), we make sure they stay stress-free at each stage of life. The result? Birds that are juicy and unbelievably flavorful.

Pork

They have pork options from Duroc, Berkshire, and Chester White pork heritage breed pigs. Heritage breed pigs are special. Their natural, “old-world” genetics mean that during their slow maturation process, they develop the fine marbling and great flavor that nature intended them to have.

Final Thoughts on How Much Does ButcherBox Cost

I have supported them now for almost three years, not once have I wavered in continuing my monthly box. I don’t know how I would find the quality of meats locally if I was to cancel this and my wife may actually kill me.

Only once has a order been missing an item and when I reached out they immediately sent me a much larger brisket in the next box which was significantly nicer than the missing steak!

I would love to hear about your experience and whether you have ordered from them before, if you haven’t and decide to order today I would love to hear what you thought of your first box and if you will continue to order!

I grew up in a home where most our days were spent inside, and sports were not a family priority. I did play soccer and baseball as a kid, but the older I got, the more I lost interest. To regain my health, I decided to adhere to the three tenets of health and longevity. I hope you will join me, by making it your purpose to live as long and well as possible.